Here's an unusual Jaguar V8 engine failure for you . . .
We got this 2003 Jaguar after another shop replaced failed secondary timing chain tensioners. They replaced the tensioners and chains, cleaned out the broken bits of plastic, and thought the engine had dodged a bullet. But the engine didn’t sound right and kept leaking oil from one of the VVT solenoid ports, despite changing the seal several times.
When we ran the car, the VVT solenoid vibrated strangely under our thumb, which was unusual. We pulled the cam covers. . .
Inspection under the cam covers revealed that the integral thrust flange on the left-bank intake camshaft has fractured and broken off, allowing excessive axial camshaft movement.
We removed the oil pan and recovered the broken flange in three pieces. The grainy appearance of the fractures is consistent with an impact or sudden stress break. I have seen similar breakage patterns in cases of sudden camshaft seizure or impact.
We suspect the flange didn’t break away from the cam until after the other shop’s final motor assembly, because its failure visibly misaligned the upper chain, and their tech could have seen that.
We believe the damage most likely stemmed from the original secondary timing-chain tensioner failures. When a secondary tensioner fails, the broken pieces often get sucked into the chain, and the shock when those hit the timing gears can break the chains, the cams, or both.
The extensive wear on the recovered flange indicates significant rotational contact during the failure process, but when hard steel bears on aluminum, damage like that can happen in minutes, not months.
This is an extremely unusual breakage. Despite my 35 years’ experience with these and other similar engines, we have rarely encountered a comparable camshaft fracture. Our review of available Jaguar technical information shows no service bulletins or write-ups on this, but secondary tensioner and VVT failure are well known as causes of engine damage.
The front cover comes off next, and we will look at everything else to make sure those tensioner bits didn't cause any more hidden damage on their way to the oil pan sump.
Another day at J E Robison Service Co
My photos show the broken area, and the unbroken other side for comparison.
No comments:
Post a Comment